On Friday 9th March 2012 at approx 1.40pm, the FSA released a report censuring Bank of Scotland and particularly its Corporate loan division, for “serious misconduct.” Friday being POETS day, it’s fair to say the reaction by the press was slightly dumbed down. The weekend press did not have time to do an in depth analysis of the report and the weekly press were in the process of knocking off.
Consequently there was a bit of media attention to the report on Friday, a bit more on Saturday and by Sunday the story was all but gone. Depending on your agenda, it was a job well done.
Additionally, by Saturday (I don’t know the exact time), the link to the report on the FSA website came up with a page explaining that the FSA was having technical difficulties. I dare say that anyone desperate to read the report could have ultimately found it by trailing through the various options the site gave but, let’s face it, in a world now inundated with tales of financial greed, fraud and gloom, who really wanted to spend their weekend trying to find a report on a bank we already knew was a basket case?
The usual diehards put up comments on the various articles (I was too shocked by the report to make immediate comment), the tweeters tweeted (yes I did do that) and, for the time being, it seems that is that.
As someone with a particular interest in what went on at HBOS I was genuinely surprised by the FSA report – for many reasons and not least because it appears to be more transparent than I imagined it would be. Regardless of the fact it did not name names and it used bizarre words like ‘optimism’ to replace the blatantly more obvious nouns it could have used, there is no doubt that, however late in the day, the FSA have decided to expose some of the truths behind the failure at HBOS.
OMG – I have just written a sentence that is so dumbed down it could have been written by the FSA!
Anyway, the report is out and despite the fact it has appeared to come and go with little or no public outrage, I believe no amount of careful timing will stop it eventually exploding as the time bomb it is. There is a reason the FSA have published a document that puts not only a major bank but also its own organisation in such bad light. Maybe the reason will become more apparent when the 6 redacted paragraphs contained in the report come to light. Almost certainly we will all know more when the criminal investigation into HBOS reaches its conclusions.
The fact that some people outside the Bank or the FSA have substantial information surrounding events at HBOS may have been another determining factor. But one way or another, even the biggest critics of the regulator (including me) will have to admit that by publishing the details surrounding the censure of Bank of Scotland in the public domain, the FSA have pushed a reluctant snowball up to the top of the hill. And now, nothing can stop it rolling down at high speed before landing with a crash that will deliver an avalanche of very unpleasant truths that will finally blow the lid off the myths of La la Land.
Timing is everything and, even although a Friday afternoon is perhaps the least inspiring time to release such an important document, it does still mean the clock on the Bank of Scotland is now ticking very loudly. So for once, I have to say, the FSA appears to have done its job and in doing so, it has done itself no favours. And maybe that is the biggest conundrum? At a time when the FSA is still facing a barrage of criticism over the RBS debacle, was this the best time to lay itself open to even more about Bank of Scotland? I have my own idea’s but, whatever the reason, it has got to be HUGE.